* This article was first published in Blank Canvas Magazine, Fall 2009.
The Schube: I know who masterminded the JFK assassination.
He butted in front of me at the 12-items-or-less checkout line at the Fresh & Easy. He had three items too many, but the kid behind the counter didn’t mention it. Maybe the kid had him pegged too.
I know who murdered Jon Benet Ramsey.
She boarded the bus right after me and stared straight ahead in a trance all the way to downtown Phoenix. A Daewoo darted out in the carpool lane and everyone else braced for it as the brakes burned, but she never tensed up. Just faced forward and kept on fiddling with the hairs in the mole on her neck. That’s when I knew the unspeakable things she’s done.
I ran into a guy who knows exactly where Jimmy Hoffa is buried.
I wasn’t brave enough to ask him. I didn’t like the way his pockmarked face glared at me outside the Chicken Man in New Orleans as he picked through an ashtray for something with enough tobacco left to smoke. I kept my head down and walked on by. Went in and bought a bag of mesquite BBQ corn nuts from a guy behind the counter whose story would undoubtedly scar you for life.
It’s amazing what you can figure out about people. It took me a little while to get the hang of it, and now I can’t stop.
I think it all started about two years ago on a flight from Orlando to Baltimore. My wife and I were bored and started noticing the little quirks of people on the plane. About once an hour, a guy in his mid-80s a few seats away would pull out an envelope and carefully unfold a handwritten letter. He’d read it and wipe a tear from his right eye, then put the note back in his breast pocket.
I’m still haunted by what that note might have said. The reporter in me was dying to know. I wanted to reach over and tap him on the forearm and ask if everything was OK, if he wanted to talk about it. Because maybe then he’d tell me.
But instead, I let my imagination drift. I made up a whole back story about the guy in my mind, and it really seemed to fit him perfectly. This was a long flight, so I had plenty of time to add all sorts of details, to the point where the he just became that character to me.
In my mind, the letter was from his granddaughter. They’d had a falling out nearly a decade ago when she found out that he’d lied to her for years about being a CEO of a knife manufacturing company. She’d stumbled across the secret no one else in the family knew: He was actually a hired killer.
She loved him enough to never tell anyone, but cast him out of her life. It nearly destroyed him because she was all he had.
Then two days ago, her letter arrived like a brick through a window. I need help, grandpa. His fingers trembled as he read on. There was nowhere else to turn. She’d married a police commander and everything had been great until he started beating her. Twice he’d put her in the hospital. Last week, he’d threatened to kill her if she tried to leave. The cops didn’t believe her. He had too much influence.
Please, grandpa. I know I shut you out but I couldn’t bear to know you’d done those things. Now you might be the only person who can help.
The old man had retired nearly 25 years ago, and his body was failing him. He was tired, so tired. His hands shook with arthritis. But they steadied a little more each time he read her letter. Her words filled him with bittersweet hope that he could make things right between them this time. He knew what needed to be done. When the plane touched down in Maryland, he was going to take her husband’s life.
Now, every day, I find myself coming up with these stories about random strangers. Sometimes it feels like a blessing, and it’s often very funny to see what your imagination comes up with. (The traffic lady directs an underground freak show every Wednesday night that’s a riot!)
Other times, it’s a little intense. I mean, this morning I met the Zodiac Killer in the bargain books section of Barnes & Noble. The guy behind me at the Chick-fil-A drive-through once filled in for Josef Mengele when the mad Nazi doctor was out for a few days with a cold.
You see?
Oh, and I know about you, too. I know what wanders through your mind, where your hands have been. I know what you’ve been up to.
You know about me, too. Or you will. Because now that I’ve told you about this, about making up stories about strangers, you’ll start doing it too. Just wait and see.
One day you’ll pull up beside me at a red light and you’ll glance my way. Your mind will start to wander. You won’t be sure about who I really am, but in your mind, you’ll know.
You’ll know.

